Jump to content
Show header slider

ELECTRIC SIGN SUPPLIES
If You're Looking For Premium Electric Sign Industry Components From Trim Cap, LED's, Neon Supplies, Power Supplies, Pattern Paper.  Then Please Visit Our Online Store or Feel Free To Call Us For Inquiries or Placing an Order!!
Buy Now

SIGN INSTALLER MAP
Looking for a fellow Sign Syndicate Company Member For A Sign Install or Maintenance Call?
Click Here

For Sign Company's Who Work As Subcontractors
Before You Work For A National Sign & Service Company You Need To Look At The Reviews Of These Companies Before You Work For Them. Learn When To Expect Payment From Them and What It's Like To Work For Them, The Good, The Bad, The Ugly. Learn and Share Your Experiences Yourself For Others
Click Here

NEON vs LED article

chatterbox

By chatterbox
in Trade Magazines

 Share

Recommended Posts

chatterbox Apprentice

chatterbox

Posted
Posted

This is Mike from Chatterbox Designs in Los Angeles.

I was researching the web as I do on a number of topics as is customary based on my job as Business Development in the Sign Industry.

I am no expert on NEON or LED. I have been involved with designing signs for about 10 years with both electrical components.

I came across this article on ELRO SIGNS. I wonder if you could read up on it and authenticate the information. As you are the expert, as are other members on the Sign Syndicate.

http://www.elrosigns.com/

Please let me know as, to me, it just sounds like surface information. There is a lot more to this NEON vs. LED thing.

Thanks.

Mike B.

Chatterbox Designs

Los Angeles, CA

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Erik Sine Master Engineer

Erik Sine

Posted
Posted

This article is a year old but I do know Frank Rhodes has the same opinion about the light sources he describes in his article.

It's very unfortunate that Frank Rhodes of Elro Signs has had very bad experiences with CCFL or neon lamps for channel letters. He's in California just like myself and he describes a 90 warranty (Illegal warranty for CA as a licensed contractor) and in a typical set of neon illuminated channel letters they get a return trip for service once a year. Like a lot of LED marketing statements we see the typical save 60-80% in energy over neon.

What's very sad and hurtful for our trade is the fact that Frank submitted and published this article to the construction trade with incorrect facts and an omission of facts and once again like our own Trade Magazines Neon gets mis-characterized.

The fact is LED's can save 60-80% in energy consumption but what he failed to tell the readers is, what is the light output level? Is it just as bright for the discount in energy? NO! I could install a few night lights in letters as well and have significant savings exceeding 80%. Further to be said, neon on what, Magnetic or Electronic transformer.

If Mr Rhodes is having to return to service his neon illuminated channel letters once a year or once every couple of years then he's not installing his channel letters correctly and probably doesn't have the loads correct, or he has a god awful neon bender who processes them poorly. The fact is, anyone who knows somewhat to a degree of what they are doing knows and has experienced that they won't be returning for years and years. Personally speaking for my business my standard warranty for neon channel letters is 5 years, but that's just me, sometimes I extend that depending on the circumstances. Yes, small freak things happen like small crack or leaks and most case you find this out within the first 30 days. I'll be posting up a job and testimonial soon of a channel letter job that is 15+ years old that of which I have never returned back for any service (like most of my jobs, I hardly ever return). It's hard these days in San Diego to find a customer who is still in business or still has the same sign for that length in time hasn't moved, etc that I can use as an example, but there it is.

Frank also explains the con in Neon when it comes to cold temperatures, he is correct with a half truth. What he failed to mention is the flip side of the coin, he didn't mention the fact that LED's dim in hot temps and this can lead to failure in extreme zones.

I don't know anything more humorous in this article than hearing "Neon cannot compare with LEDs in reliability". Again, Frank's company might need help in his production and installation department. His statements too regarding neon, he seems to contradict himself as he states Neon is not as reliable as LEDs but yet, it can "last decades...with regular maintenance". But a standard warranty for lamps are 90 days? I'm confused

One big HUGE omission on his part when it comes to regular maintenance of LED's is the fact that should a small string or a few modules go out by his pick in LED product, upon his return trip he may just learn that the modules chosen for his sing may not even exist anymore. "Well dear client I have to inform you this particular product is no longer on the market, there has been two or three more generations of this module since.......COMPLETE retrofit!"

I understand the importance of LEDs as another option to light up your signs. I understand the shipping stress aspect of neon. I understand some may have crappy installers that don't give a flying shit when handling neon, or under experienced project planners and journeymen. I've seen the worst installs by big companies and it may be they don't know what the hell they are doing, it maybe lazy workers not doing what THEY are supposed to be doing. I GET all THAT!!!!

In the end, and I've already said it hundreds of times, you use the right or best light source you can for THAT application. End of story! It's not good for our trade and industry to harp on Neon and other light sources by mis-characterizing it with untrue facts, twisted figures and omission of facts all in the name of selling your companies products to others. I'll say it again, "It's not good for OUR Trade & Industry!"

There's plenty of holes and room for debate but I don't have time to list all, I'm SURE others will be chiming in. I just wanted to point out a few.

You have enemies? Good. That means you've stood up for something, sometime in your life. - Winston Churchill

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Erik Sine
      The Great White Hope IV

      By Erik Sine · Posted

      Thanks Gary, hope all is well...sorry I caught this late 😁
    • imanut
      The Great White Hope IV

      By imanut · Posted

      And have a great 52nd birthday bash tomorrow, Eric!
    • HansonSigns
      Sign Sales Rep needed!

      By HansonSigns · Posted

      Sign Sales Hanson Sign Company, located on the beautiful Kitsap Peninsula in Washington State, has been in business since 1964.  We are known for the great care we take with clients and employees alike.  All our employees are long term and committed to fabricating and installing the best signs we can produce.  We take pride in our work! The Sign Sales representative will be responsible for A) Communicating with the customer to find their needs/wants and budget B) Communicating with our permit staff to find out what signage the customer is allowed to have per code for the particular location C) Communicating with our designer to get sketches of the sign to the customer. Also, Sales Representative will be responsible for pricing out each job to present the customer with a proposal and sign sketch. Sales Rep will maintain contact with customer to build trust and a long term relationship.  A large percentage of our customers are repeat customers or referrals from existing customers.  Requirements:  At least 3 years of sign-related employment.  Job type:  Full time, some overtime.  Hours are 7:30am to 4:00pm Monday – Friday.  Salary:  $30 -  per hour, negotiable depending on experience.  Benefits:  100% paid medical, dental, vision plan.  Matching 401K, paid vacation and holidays.  Drug testing and employment physical may be required.  Please visit our website at www.hansonsigns.com and send your resume to info@hansonsigns.com.
    • HansonSigns
      Sign Journeyman on Kitsap Peninsula

      By HansonSigns · Posted

      Looking for a Journeyman! 
    • Erik Sine
      The Great White Hope IV

      By Erik Sine · Posted

      It's been a minute since I've been active on the Sign Syndicate I must admit.   Real Life activities along with how busy I have been with developing our Brighton LED Line have taken me away from keeping this site active.  I wasn't expecting the Brighton LED line to really take off as it has.  It's required a lot of attention and I'm purposely trying to keep product circle on who sells it small.  Quality is where my focus lays and not Quantity.  I have no desire to be the next Principal LED where I get to a point where I'm just selling off a name and let the product quality drop.   Since the Principal LED gobble up of the Sloan, Hanley the whole quality in the market place has turned to absolute Dog Shit.....and that is what Shops have been buying...Dog Shit...and they don't even know it   Over the last few years it's been a race to the bottom.   Wensco, Spandex, Montroy is raging over Principal LED dropping them as a supplier so their rage is focused on their United LED by G2G to complete against Principal / Sloan.    Then we have Everylite Raging over G2G which is nothing more than old G2G Employee/Partners splitting off to do their own thing as Everylite bitter at their previous place of buisiness or employment.  So Battle Lines are all over the market place and they're all competing for one thing...who can sell the Cheapest Module.   We've discussed a lot of this in ad nauseam      Chip quality in LED Modules has gone down and price has gone up with the big monopoly along with having fewer choices at the Sign Supplier...All a mixed bag in conjunction in who can sell quantity over quality.     This will all get very interesting, real fast         So.....I have a need fever, and the only prescription is...... more Benchmark Testing.         The Great White Hope IV   Just like the predecessors of the GWH III to the original we started back in 2009 we will test the Original Light output of various Vendor LEDs with similar spacing, monitor the Lumen Maintenance (Light Degradation over time) in measuring the Luminance in Foot Candles...or the light output on a sign face....as that is all we care about in the Electric Sign Industry     Project Great White Hope      We will also display one of the most important qualities when it comes to LED Chip quality that must be given attention too, that many either not know of, or really is never talked about because it cuts through all the Marketing Bullshit and that is the Foot Candles per Watt....this is the Chip Efficiency of an LED and this number will reflect how much light output you are getting for power put it.  The higher the FC/W, the better quality chip that LED has in it.  You can't get High Light Output from poor quality chips, only high quality chip have a higher efficiency to give you more light for lesser power.   For obvious reasons I will not be benchmarking every product out there on the market, just the most visible in the Market Place.     Project Tight Whitey     For example I will not be testing Principal LED's Synergy Mini or any in the family.    A .46w LED module with poor lumen per watt is not worth investing our time to test especially at nearly $400 per bag in cost.  To me it's a joke of a product, something with such low output that will last you a long time because it operates/drives too low but you will literally need two to two and a half of these modules that one single LED module will do.  So having four .46w modules next to four Qwik Mod II modules would look ridiculous next to one another in a benchmark comparison.    Also, a lot of Modules are being phased out....   Our current line up will be the following   United LEDs (G2G).8w for Channel Letters   United LEDs (G2G) 1.2w for Large Channel Letters & Cabinets Principal Hanley's The One 1w LED Principal Qwik Mod II .8w Principal Qwik Mod II .8w Red Principal Sloans Prism .96w LED G2G Wow .8w Module Everylite Rebel 1w Module Everylite 2D .72w Module   BrightON II .8w LED Module BrightON II .8w LED Module Ruby Red BrightON III 1.2w LED Module BrightON IV 1.6w LED Module BrightON SunFire 2.4w LED Module BrightON Lightning .68w LED Module BrightON Lightning .72w LED Module Ruby Red   A few more surprise Vendor Modules as we go along.   There is no better way to show the Electric Sign Industry and where we sit with the components we use in the signs we produce than creating a benchmark comparison   I should have this up and running in the next day or two, I will create a new topic and post here publicly for all to see and monitor over the next few years.   Like the previous Benchmarks, all LED Modules will be equally spaced for 2LED Modules, 3LED Modules, and 4LED Module.    All LED Modules will be in 5" Depth Channels that are 24" x 4.25".  Sign Faces will be 1/8" 7328 White by Plexiglas grade C and all will operate by a shared France Lighting Solutions TruPower LED PSU.    The only fault this benchmark comparison will have is that the budget Constant Voltage LEDs like the Qwik Mod II will be handy capped in Light Output because there will not be any remote slight voltage drop coming from a TruPower LED PSU that will affect the light output drop that would occur in real life setting should a LED PSU be loaded at 80 - 85%.  Constant Current LED Modules light output is not affected by slight voltage drops and remain consistent in lighting.   So, if we have one fault it lays here, but just know...all Constant Voltage LED modules would normally be a little dimmer in light for two reasons, TruPower LED Power Supply and for the fact that our PSU's will not be reaching anywhere near loadable capacity, and if we were to add modules down the road after initial start, it would affect these CC LED Modules Light Output in robbing voltage.       Great White Hope Monthly Benchmark Evaluation        The Reason I'm rebooting this much needed Benchmark Comparison for the Electric Sign Industry is for a couple of reasons.  Our Trade Needs this because too many Custom Sign Shops only knowledge base it dependent on what Sign Suppliers tell them...which is way too reliant on a poor source based on the importance on sales and who they sell now and not yesterday.  I also notice with Social Media which is another poor source of reliable knowledge, has been very incorrect and very biased based on who they sell and who their relationships are built around.  This simple Benchmark will shed light where there has a lot of poor light on the subject matter   This time with our own developed LED line will be in the mix, and of course it will be seeing as biased....in a sense it will come off that way....  But I always have encouraged custom sign shops to develop their own comparisons and really, REALLY see for themselves....as Seeing is BELIEVING        More to come......
×
×
  • Create New...