Jump to content

ELECTRIC SIGN SUPPLIES
If You're Looking For Premium Electric Sign Industry Components From Trim Cap, LED's, Neon Supplies, Power Supplies, Pattern Paper.  Then Please Visit Our Online Store or Feel Free To Call Us For Inquiries or Placing an Order!!
Buy Now

SIGN INSTALLER MAP
Looking for a fellow Sign Syndicate Company Member For A Sign Install or Maintenance Call?
Click Here

For Sign Company's Who Work As Subcontractors
Before You Work For A National Sign & Service Company You Need To Look At The Reviews Of These Companies Before You Work For Them. Learn When To Expect Payment From Them and What It's Like To Work For Them, The Good, The Bad, The Ugly. Learn and Share Your Experiences Yourself For Others

Click Here

Why I say NOT China for LED's and other products


Recommended Posts

"NOT MADE IN CHINA!!"




I would like to share a document with you I was recently given, somethings are debatable in some issues but a good chunk should be payed attention too.



The LED DelusionV2.pdf




Sometimes I get people asking me why I say "NOT made in CHINA!!!" on a lot of our advertising when it comes to products we distribute on the Sign Syndicate like our infamous NC LED's.



The answer has always been simple.



China manipulates their currency which provides a disadvantage when it comes to trade, it's unfair, unequal trade. American companies who have gone to Chinese plants for production for decades...think "Engineered In America, Made In China" philosophy has always resulted in playing musical chairs because unless you have an engineer, someone you can trust to watch these plants and observe or conduct your own quality control on a daily basis, more often than not things get changed up to cut costs. More often than not, that enforcer for quality control most likely will only show up quarterly or yearly.



Standards



Socialism versus Capitalism, who do you think has a higher incentive to do better?



Human rights, there is no such thing when it comes to China and how can there be under a dictatorship.



Chinese government/industrial hackers of our computer systems



It's clear until we greatly deregulate our own country so we can bring back jobs and production in our very own country, until that happens which will be hopefully soon we should be careful about who we buy from when we can as much as possible.



When it comes to our own electric sign industry, things maybe cheaper to buy Chinese BUT the quality is almost never there unless you have VERY tight quality control and when it comes to LED's from our own tests we have been running since 2008, we haven't seen it.



As that saying goes, "buy the best, and only cry once"





post-3-0-88861100-1462047261.jpg


You have enemies? Good. That means you've stood up for something, sometime in your life. - Winston Churchill

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Board Patron

Standards

Socialism versus Capitalism, who do you think has a higher incentive to do better?

I agree with most of the China-vs-West ideas, but I think China in a business sense is more capitalistic than the US and other rich Western countries. A dear friend of mine runs a business in Hong Kong. As as business you can pretty much do what you want there. Copyrights, environmental regulations, truth in advertising, etc. are not strictly enforced. Money dictates the rules. The government is of course very anti-democratic - but I think business there is much more slanted toward pure capitalism than many other places.

Capitalism does provide incentive to work harder and do better... but "do better" means what? In a pure sense it means to make more money for yourself. Period. You can be very financially successful and create mass-misery, poison people, and destroy the environment at the same time. There is no incentive in pure capitalism to create jobs. On the contrary, a job is a liability and cost to be eliminated.

Think of countries with products most consider well made: South Korea, Japan, Switzerland, Germany, Sweden, France. All are considerably more socialist than China, Vietnam, Indonesia, Pakistan, etc, which all crank out cheap products.

Agree there are few is any standards coming out of China. But standards mean regulation. Even if voluntary, someone has to confirm and/or track compliance?

I don't mean to sound unpatriotic, but I think this county's problem is we let big monopolies exist and don't foster enough competition. And it's getting much worse. We have a punishing copyright and patent system that rewards the status quo with ever increasing winfalls. What's a copyright now... something like 60 years after the author's death??? Drug patents renewed when you change a word in the prescribing instructions? We allow pharmaceutical companies to buy up competitors and shut them down. We have the crappiest, slowest, most expensive internet service of any rich country, and we are still approving mergers of the 4 companies that control 80% of the market?

And lastly lets not forget banking.... which used to be here to provide working capital to businesses. Now they exist completely to enrich themselves and aren't even required to to operate in the best interest of their clients. Wtf?

(off my soapbox now and back to work. I swear there was a point in here somewhere about LED's....)

Edited by megavolt512
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can agree with most of that.

So rings true they can do whatever they want, and so we do not operate on a level playing field when it comes to trade, let alone operations.

People will always start and run a business to make money for themselves, to turn a profit....usually the reason being they prefer to not work under someone. The incentive is, if you have an idea, where would you rather be, here or China? We're too over regulated and you're right, some other countries do have more freedom and less restriction but the drawback is the individual liberty and right to prosper is NOT there. But shame on us for letting it get this way.

Standards are also set by the individual, or the company not necessary the government or in forms of regulation. Most set their own standards to build better products, services and performance to separate themselves from their competition and probably the reason why we get innovation set from personal standards and not ones set from government . As it relates to China and LED's well, we've all seen the companies that come here, advertise a here now gone tomorrow so much for the 80,000 hr warranty on cheap grade chips. Warranties offered for 50,000 hours, 5 years from a actual diode manufacture who only offers 3....false advertising.

Most started with a great idea, acted on it and started a business. The purpose of a business is not to create jobs but to turn a profit, however an awesome byproduct of a business are jobs. Companies will thrive and grow with great employees.

On monopolies, the interesting part about the collaboration of various large companies usually occurs when the people let government get bigger, more regulation, and so starts the overreach. In reaction, large companies bind together and merge to become larger to protect themselves and their way of doing business. This generally does not happen with smaller government and low regulation, it's easier to operate and compete

But funny point on companies buying others to shut them down or have those products permanently shelved, we've seen plenty of that in this industry alone.....I suppose I could mention names. But just think about what you enjoyed using that you do not have anymore, lol

All in all, we still live in the best country this world has ever seen, AND a country that has only been around a little over 200 years, no other country values individual/personal rights, liberties & freedoms. Others can try and copy, but "freedom" is never enough WITHOUT responsibility and virtue. Without those qualities it becomes a soggy mushy mess......and why America is exceptional, and why others flock to the idea of "Freedom"

My Sunday thoughts.... :crazy_pilot:

  • Like 2

You have enemies? Good. That means you've stood up for something, sometime in your life. - Winston Churchill

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Regarding sign products from China, the issues we have always seen is quality control. Every company says they have "best quality" but in reality they have zero quality control. Every product you order has problems, and every one is different from the last making them incompatible.

Chinese companies will change what you order without telling you and just expect you to be okay with it.

Their warranties are worthless, as you can't ship any "used" products in to their country, so it's impossible to take advantage of their warranties.

There's a tremendous time delay when dealing with China. You ask a question, they respond the next day (usually not even answering your question but instead asking you something that you've already answered in a previous email). If you have a liaison that speaks the dialect and can be a middle-man that is great if your middle-man knows the product and problems and can ask the right questions. Otherwise, every time you want to talk to them you have to set up a midnight meeting and pay your middle-man to translate for you.

It's really hard to provide a quality product if you're ordering it from China, and it's near impossible to do it in a timely manner and keep your customer from being furious at you!

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 9 months later...

It is the truth that the quality control in China is a problem . Some plants may sell their poor quality led sign and mislead them their customer , tell them the sign as same quality as sign manufactured in US , I think this  should be blamed .  but some others Chinese suppliers tell the customer the true market position their products should be at.( for example , our products are aimed at middle - high end market. Then US customer can adjust accordingly when selling the sign to end user or resellers. for example , buying more spare parts( modules,control card, receiving card , flat cable , sensor ) if sign shows problem , they can send out the parts immediately for replacement , then his customer send back those bad modules or other cards, then , he can send back those back parts together to Chinese supplier . and target customer should be those customers who want to have a led sign but can not afford a sign like Daktronics or Watchfire.  In this way , I believe the US buyer can gain more customers  and more profit . 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Oh that's cool.   Probably better articles too
    • I get emails from the mag and they have started to put early issues into an archive with the Cincinnatti public library.   it's facinating to look at the old copies, especially the ads for the various products.   EG sign lights with a hooded reflector don't seem to have changed much in design since the 1920's.    I've put a link to the archive below.  i hope they keep doing this because i'd love to see issues from the 1960's/70's when i first started helping my Dad.   https://digital.cincinnatilibrary.org/digital/collection/p16998coll17/search/searchterm/Collection of SmartWork Media/field/source/mode/exact/conn/and/order/datea/ad/asc
    • A long time ago I did a comparison between the different colors of neon with my eldest daughter.  It was for a science fair project.   We took 7-8 different neon samples (i had a ton at the time) and put a light meter on the various colors.   Clear red put out the most light by a good margin.   i don't have the info anymore because that was about 30 years ago but it does make sense to put red LED's behind red plex.    And we used to put red neon behind red faces - way back when - so red modules behind red faces is logical.  
    • We had a long time Mexican Restaurant customer switch out his clear red 15 mm neon for LEDs.  He thought our price was too high for LEDs so he used an unexperienced sign company and they installed cheap white Chinese LEDs behind his old faces. His faces went from red to pink (rosa) at night. Needless to say he wasn’t happy with pink faces… He pointed this out to the other Sign company, but they would not fix it. Plus, they had no clue what they were doing with the parking lot lighting as they tried replacing 400 W metal halide lamps with LEDs. He immediately called us to fix his parking lot lights because he was losing business because his parking lot was dark. He lived with the pink letters at night for a while and just recently hired us to install red LEDs and remove the white ones. He’s happy now with red faces again at night.
    • This is a great comparison to show why it's always best to use Red LEDs behind Red Faces, and not use White for everything.     On the left is the one of the brightest white LEDs on the market...The .8watt BrightON II LED Module, on the right the BrightON Ruby Red…also .8 watts per module and probably thee brightest Red LED module on the Market.          When we put a 7328 White acrylic sign face over the white we get a luminance of 240 Foot Candles of Light right on the sign surface .  Now we’ll switch the White acrylic with another 7328 White Acrylic with 3M Red 3630-30 Applied Translucent vinyl and see the results.         Red is very hard to capture using an iPhone, but believe me…..in person the contrast between the channels that has the White LEDS vs the Red LEDs is large.  The Red is overwhelmingly brighter than the White with a luminance on the sign face with 47 Foot Candles….and the White LEDs with a luminance of ONLY 18 Foot Candles.         When using White LEDs behind a Red face you will lose 50% of the luminance on the sign face based on how the lens filters the wavelengths.  This is why it’s best to use Colors behind Colors….Most of the time!    
×
  • Create New...